Plato: Complete Works

I got this edition of Plato's Works back in March, as I wanted, not only a TRULY COMPLETE edition of Plato, but modern translations as well. I have an MA in History, but one of my BA's is in Philosophy, with an emphasis in Early Western and Scholastic Philosophy. Over the years since, I have read many philosophers, from Plato, to Marx, to Mao, and many more. But ultimately, it ALL goes back to Plato. As Alfred North Whitehead said, all philosophy AFTER Plato was and is footnotes to him. And one cannot argue that Plato was to Western Civilisation every bit as important as Moses, and the other Biblical writers, and possibly moreso. This particular book is well-bound, with a dust jacket. I got it from a private seller at Amazon, and if memory serves it was listed as VERY GOOD condition, which it is in fact. There is some minor underlining at the beginning of the text, but that is all. Buying this book hard-copy for US$35 is a steal. Back to the content. These are all modern translations. I am used to the Jowett translations, which are all VERY dry. These are much easier to read. My knowledge of Greek is extremely limited, and even then mostly New Testament Greek, which is an entirely different dialect, for lack of a better word, than what Plato used. My personal recommendation is that, if you are reading merely for basic knowledge, use this text. If you are a true scholar of Plato (as I fancy myself to be), STILL use this text, as well as other translations, including Jowett, for comparison. Better yet, learn the original Greek! For those of us who cannot learn Greek at this time, this book is a jewel. It contains EVERYTHING, either written by Plato, or thought to be, or that even came to us under his name, spuriously so. It is THE MOST COMPLETE edition out there. Plato is the real deal. Reading him will set you to truly understand the human condition. There is no one, not Aristotle, not Moses, and I would dare to say, not even Jesus (and I say that as a Christian!), who can impart the kind of knowledge that Plato can. One who does not read him cannot be said to be any kind of scholar. In fact, if I may be so bold, I would say that reading Plato is necessary to even be truly human. In sum, I encourage EVERY PERSON who is literate to read this book. In fact, it SHOULD be required reading in EVERY high school across the land. The only reason it isn't is because, as a previous reviewer noted, the government (which controls the curriculum in our schools) would be terrified of people actually learning to THINK for themselves.

“Plato: Complete Works” stands as the single best edition of complete works of Plato currently extant. There are alternatives, but I caution buyers against those, because they are, so far as I am aware, all compilations of the public domain translations. For the casual reader who would like to have a cursory knowledge of the dialogues, and who also doesn’t mind a little roughness to the translation, those compilations are fine, and by no means bad for that purposed. One such example, which used to be my primary source, was The Great Books of the Western World’s edition of Plato, volume VI of the set, if I remember correctly. The difference between these two mentioned editions ranges from minor to substantial. For instances, “Plato: Complete Works” contains Jowett translations that are altered, because, when Jowett was translating from the Greek, he sought to eliminate homosexual allusions and imagery from the text, so that it was more palatable to Victorian English culture. I have found the translations in the reviewed title to be smoother and the format better (e.g., the GBWW contain two columns on each page, which usually lends to faster reading, but not when it comes to dialogues, for some reason). For a large book, the volume is actually pretty easy to wield, no more difficult than, say, it would be to handle a bible. The quality of the binding is considerable, though I do know that there seems to have been some printings with quite a few defective copies, where the pages are not sewn in very well. Beware of this, when purchasing. Otherwise, I have had no problem and use my volume quite often. As a plug for the content of the book, over and beyond this particular edition, I can’t say how important it is for the intellectual mind, the well-informed individual, the human being, i.e., layperson searching for meaning, and the scholar to read Plato and Aristotle. So much of the whole of history is a continual recapitulation of these thinkers’ ideas, and so it is extraordinarily difficult to truly appreciate subsequent original thought, when one hasn’t the least idea about what it is, exactly that a thinker has said that is new. The tone was set by Plato in many areas of thought: aesthetics, epistemology, science, ontology, cultural and literary critique, etc. With so many histories having historiographically embraced Plato and Aristotle as the originators of ideas the humanity would wrestle with to present (e.g., “The Passion of the Western Mind” by Tarnas, “The Cave and the Light” by Herman, etc.), Plato’s works comprise much of what is at the core of the human intellectual tradition, and I highly recommend everyone having at least sampled them, from middle school to high school, from undergrad to grad, from layperson to scholar. Alfred North Whitehead once remarked that history [and, really, intelligent thought, in general] is a series of footnotes to Plato. He’s not too far off with the comment, and it certainly can’t be regarded as an exaggeration, by any means. Edition and content recommended to absolutely everyone willing to read it. I suggest putting everything aside, and take the time to read, skim, and peruse this anthology.

Very well collected and organized! I quite liked the introduction and overview in the beginning of the book; it provides a wonderful context to Plato’s works and Socratic dialogues as a whole—making the text approachable for any audience. There is also a plethora of authors notes on words and sections that require contextual explanations to understand. I like how the author went this direction as apposed to modifying the translated text in such a way that I feel further misinterprets what is meant in its original form. Of course unless you can read ancient text in its original language, you’re always going to lose a little meaning in the process, but from the other books I’ve read this seems to be the most organic and understandable form. Finally the book protector is pretty and the book cover fits very nice in my collection!

Using solely simple English and understandable terms, in the style which the texts were originally composed by Plato himself, the translators and editors of this Hackett version of Plato successfully brought the classics of paramount significance in western civilization to curious and studious readers in the modern era. What else can I say? Just buy it! Surely you won't regret. Pros 1) Beautiful hard cover for collectors. (Well, if you really desire the insights of Plato, you should make the book as dirty as possible after you read it, raping it with your markers and margin notes.) 2) The style of writing: as I mentioned in the introductory part of this review. 3) Full Stephanus pagination is provided throughout the entire work, making it extremely convenient to the readers for scholarly research, and discussion/comparison with other people. 4) Introductory passages, to both the way you should study Plato in the beginning chapters of the book, and before each of Plato's dialogues, helping the reader to get a grand picture at first, so that you can decide, after you read the introduction, that if you really need to read the dialogues. However, I'd suggest you read all his works in its entirety, at least those that are generally agreed by scholars to be Plato's genuine work. Cons The only issue of this great thing is of course the quality of its printing. The pages are very thin, like the kind of paper used in printing dictionaries and the bible. As regards this aspect, I'd prefer the polished paper used in Cambridge classics. Font size (approximately 11 pt serif font) is okay for youngsters, but I would suggest the elderly to get magnifying glasses for reading this.

I've been reading this edition of Plato's Complete Works cover-to-cover, and I'm almost at the end of reading the dialogue "Laws" of this Complete Works (which is the last major dialogue in this edition, with the rest 100-150 being the spurious writings historically attributed to Plato and non-dialogue works like his "Letters"). The translations are pretty readable and nice. But what I like most about this edition is how it's nicely the format is with how it chronologically places the dialogues in a order that best makes sense for someone new to Plato to get introduced to, and how it locates dialogues that make sense to read together, based on their continuation or relevancy to the setting or topic of the dialogue, next to each other. Such as the first 4 dialogues in this edition: "Euthyphro" -- which occurs before Socrates' hearing, "Apology" -- Socrates defense during his trial, Crito -- occurs after his sentence but before his execution, and Phaedo -- which occurs during his execution and death; the first 3 are pretty short and easy to get into if you're relatively new to philosophy, and Phaedo, which makes sense to read chronologically after them, is the start of getting into some of Plato's deeper beliefs that aren't him critiquing the popular topics of his day. Then, after those, the proceeding dialogues are Theaetetus-Sophist-Statesman-Parmenides, which are linked to the same setting, followed by Philebus (which is sort of similar in theme of what is knowledge to the previous 4). Then Symposium and Phaedrus -- both centered on love and beauty. Next comes the First and Second Alcibiades and Hipparchus, which loosely share the theme of vice and greed, which is followed by Rival Lovers and Theages, both based on what kind of education one should focus on attaining. Theages's placement, in my opinion, marks the official start of the discussion of virtue in this edition with the following dialogue, as it's proceeded by Charmides-Laches-Lysis; which are then followed by the Sophist-centered dialogues (Euthydemus-Protagoras-Gorgias-Meno-Greater Hippias-Lesser Hippias) that pretty much talk about the same subject but with Plato's rebuttal of the practices and beliefs of the prominent Sophists of his day. The next chronological dialogues after that and before the Republic are Ion, Menexenus, and Clitophon, all of which center the integrity of orators. Finally, you get to the notorious Republic, which is pretty long and includes various subjects and topics discussed in the previous mentioned dialogues; which is followed by Timaeus and Critias which are continuations in the same setting. Then you get Minos, a fitting introduction dialogue for the theme that is in "Laws", and finally "Laws" -- Plato's longest and perhaps last major work (that we have), that is a more pragmatic-contrasted version of the Republic. Then you have mostly spurious and minor work that has in the past been attributed to him, that, aside from his Letters, aren't that relevant to read if you're focused on his philosophical beliefs alone. This is perhaps the best order to read his dialogues in if you really want to read all them continuously. The only fault I find in it, is the early location of Parmenides in this edition, which I believe, and is notorious for, being the most cryptically-complex and ambiguous dialogue of Plato's, that is best suited to hold-off, or to be re-read at the end. There isn't much commentary or annotation in this edition, which I can't really complain about, as Hackett's main purpose of compiling these translations was probably more aligned as making this more of reference edition for scholars and students to have and flip through for studying particular dialogues, and not a thoroughly connected study textbook for those interested of reading ALL of Plato (which many of people, besides for academic philosophers, probably don't do). So to those who are reading this, who aren't that familiar with Plato and want to read the entirety of his complete works (or a significant amount of it) I highly advise you to first read or become familiar with Homer and Hesiod with their epics, read a little bit on some of the major Pre-socratics and their beliefs, some plays or overview of Greek drama, and some of Greek history (I highly recommend reading Herodotus and Thucydides' Histories), and get something like the Cambridge Companion to Plato as commentary to read afterwards.

This is, without question, the best book of Plato out there. I’m a fan of Benjamin Jowett, but this doesn’t have a single one of his translations and I’m okay with it. This has a wonderful collection of translations (Republic particularly is easier to understand when compared to the Jowett version) and the notes are insightful, helpful, and appropriately minimal. The paper is Bible-tissue thin, you can see print on the other sides of the pages, but I’m okay with that. The print is very small, I should add. These things don’t bother me as much as they might to those of older ages. Overall though, I think this should be the Plato book you get if you are first getting into him, have been studying him for a long time, or know him like the back of your hand. Wonderful edition.

This all-in-one volume of Plato's works is almost everything you could ask for. The translation is good and relatively easy to follow. It has a general introduction, a description before every dialogue, comes in a nice red hardcover, and has every single platonic dialogue. This collection is even more valuable as it includes the spurious works and the epigrams which are hard to find published anywhere else, just for that alone this edition deserves some acknowledgement. It also features the marginal notes which are immensely helpful for scholarly works that discuss Plato. The only complaints I have is that the book itself could have been a little bigger and the lack of any critical commentary. The latter is perfectly understandable otherwise it would have stretched the book to 3 volumes instead of 1. Still, a recommended edition of Plato's works and for a very reasonable price.

This is a beautiful edition. Those who are complaining about "thin pages" are evidently not aware of something colloquially called "Bible pages". These pages are of very high paper quality and are continuing an industry standard for multi-paged reference books, anthologies, collected works, and Bibles for centuries. There is nothing wrong with this edition at all. These pages are not a ploy by the publisher to save money. It is a classic and respected printing manufacturing system. And they not "transparent". It is a joy to own this book. Highly recommended.

編集主幹はプリンストン大学哲学科教授のJohn M. Cooper教授。その他３０名の教授の翻訳で読みやすさ満点です。プラトンやその著作についての解説、また全著作をカバーしたindexもついていて本当に贅沢な造りです。プラトンを読む事の意味や、読む時に注意する事など価値ある解説が特に助かりました。 装丁、紙質ともにCODと同様です。結構気にする人もいると思うので。 小林秀雄も言うように、プラトンには哲学の専門用語は無く、文脈にしっかりついて行く姿勢さえ持っていれば読む事ができ、深い所まで考えさせてくれます。 大学受験の英文法書一冊とターゲット１９００レベルの単語帳をマスターしていれば、単語と文法においては十分読めるでしょう。多読にも使えるし精読にも使える、最高の英文素材です。

Excellent quality. Pages are necessarily thin but fine if you are careful.

Platon'un Türkçe çevirileri eksik. Çevrilmiş olanların büyük bir çoğunluğu da berbat çevirilere sahip. Alınabilecek en iyi çeviri bu. Fiyat tuzlu fakat Platon'un yazdığı her şeyi elde ediyorsunuz.

Every Plato works and works attributed to him are included in this one copy with helpful and comprehensive introductions before each translations. Besides the thin jacket and flimsy quality of pages, it was a good buy. And it'll look good on the shelf of any library.

Mottagaren blev nöjd!